3 clones found

01Dua FragrancesBlack Widow

Black Widow

by Dua Fragrances

● Top pickHigh match

~$40–55

02Alexandria FragrancesDark Knight

Dark Knight

by Alexandria Fragrances

High match

~$29–45

03Montagne ParfumsPhantom Noir

Phantom Noir

by Montagne Parfums

Moderate match

~$35–45

By Kilian Black Phantom (full name 'Black Phantom - Memento Mori') is a dark, boozy gourmand built on dark rum, roasted coffee, dark chocolate, almond/heliotrope and sugar cane over a woody-smoky base — an adult, dessert-in-a-glass scent that commands roughly $240-400 at retail, which makes it a heavily cloned target. Community consensus (Fragrantica boards, Reddit, and multiple side-by-side YouTube comparisons) coalesces most strongly around two alternatives: Dua Fragrances 'Black Widow', which is repeatedly cited as the closest overall match to the rum/coffee/chocolate accord with strong-to-slightly-heavier performance, and Alexandria Fragrances 'Dark Knight', an older, well-established interpretation praised as smoother and more refined (some prefer it, though it reads a touch more balanced/less thick than the mocha-rich original). Montagne Parfums 'Phantom Noir' is a smaller-house but faithful gourmand rendition. Honest caveats: clone accuracy tops out around 90-95%, with the main gaps in the quality of the boozy transition and the drydown; Dua and Alexandria are extrait-strength and batch/performance can vary; and several listicle-only names circulating for this fragrance (e.g. Chez Pierre 'Killer Phantom', Mod 'Black Opulence', ALT 'Caped Crusader') lacked strong independent community corroboration and were excluded here.