3 clones found

01Dua FragrancesSpiced Vanilla Extrait 21

Spiced Vanilla Extrait 21

by Dua Fragrances

● Top pickHigh match

~$50–60

02Hekayat AttarVannifolia

Vannifolia

by Hekayat Attar

Moderate match

~$30–45

03Maison AsrarVanilla Aura

Vanilla Aura

by Maison Asrar

Low match

~$35–45

Guerlain Vanille Planifolia Extrait 21 (2023, L'Art & La Matiere / Les Extraits Signature) is an opulent 30%-concentration extrait built on a headily rich vanilla planifolia tincture punctuated with warm spices and grounded in opoponax (Guerlain's ambery 'opopanine' accord), amber and musk — a grown-up, silky, faintly woody-floral vanilla rather than a sweet gourmand, retailing around $630. Because it is a costly, recent niche release, genuine long-form Reddit consensus is thin; the dupe conversation lives mostly on Fragrantica/Parfumo, TikTok and YouTube, so treat this as emerging rather than deeply-vetted consensus. Three real, independently-verifiable alternatives recur across those sources: Dua Fragrances' 'Spiced Vanilla Extrait 21' is the most faithful and note-for-note aligned (vanilla, spices, opoponax, amber, musk) and the most direct homage; Hekayat Attar's 'Vannifolia' is a hugely popular ~90% take that skews spicier/powdery-sweet with lower sillage; and Maison Asrar's viral 'Vanilla Aura' captures the overall vibe and drydown cheaply but drifts more powdery/chocolate-y and is often described as same-family rather than a true 1:1. None is claimed to fully match the original's ultra-premium raw materials; confidence is moderate given the newness and SEO-heavy dupe coverage.