5 clones found

01DossierWoody Chestnut

Woody Chestnut

by Dossier

● Top pickHigh match

~$29–42

02Montagne ParfumsMaison du Soir

Maison du Soir

by Montagne Parfums

High match

~$40

03Paris CornerEmir Camp Fire

Emir Camp Fire

by Paris Corner

High match

~$30–40

04Alexandria FragrancesCampfire Nights

Campfire Nights

by Alexandria Fragrances

High match

~$43–60

05LattafaAmeer Al Oudh Intense Oud

Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud

by Lattafa

Low match

~$18–25

Maison Margiela’s Replica By the Fireplace is a legendary cold-weather classic celebrated for its incredibly realistic 'burning wood' smoky opening that softens into a cozy, comforting blend of roasted chestnut, cloves, and sweet vanilla. Because the original EDT's longevity and projection are occasionally criticized relative to its price, a highly competitive clone market has emerged. The community favorite for a direct 1:1 match is Dossier Woody Chestnut, which captures the core DNA with a slightly tamed opening smoke. For a higher oil concentration and a incredibly smooth transition, Montagne Parfums Maison du Soir is highly esteemed, while Paris Corner Emir Camp Fire delivers an accurate, budget-friendly 'edible bonfire' scent. Those looking for stellar performance often weigh Alexandria's potent Campfire Nights alongside Lattafa's Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud, though the latter is widely recognized as a sweeter, oud-inflected alternative rather than a strict clone.