4 clones found

01DossierWoody Chestnut

Woody Chestnut

by Dossier

● Top pickHigh match

~$26–29

02Alexandria FragrancesCampfire Nights

Campfire Nights

by Alexandria Fragrances

High match

~$43–63

03The Dua BrandDua's Fireplace

Dua's Fireplace

by The Dua Brand

High match

~$33

04Lattafa PerfumesAmeer Al Oudh Intense

Ameer Al Oudh Intense

by Lattafa Perfumes

Moderate match

~$30–40

By the Fireplace (Replica) is one of the most heavily duped cozy smoky-chestnut/vanilla fragrances, so the clone landscape is deep and well-documented. Community and reviewer consensus centers on a few repeatedly-cited options. Dossier's Woody Chestnut is the near-universal budget pick, praised as a very close, faithful rendition of the smoky guaiac/cade + chestnut gourmand accord at a fraction of the price, though with only moderate performance. Alexandria Fragrances Campfire Nights is a purpose-built 2020 clone that runs slightly spicier and less woody with a richer aged-vanilla note and notably stronger sillage/longevity — widely regarded as an excellent match once macerated. The Dua Brand's 'Dua's Fireplace' is a dedicated extrait clone with a near-identical published note pyramid and strong longevity. Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense is often floated as a cheap 'in-the-same-vibe' sweeter/oudier take rather than a true 1:1 match. Main caveats across clones are batch/maceration variance (especially Alexandria) and softer openings than the original's signature first-spray bloom.