3 clones found

01Dua FragrancesCumbria

Cumbria

by Dua Fragrances

● Top pickHigh match

~$45–60

02Ard Al ZaafaranTafakhar

Tafakhar

by Ard Al Zaafaran

Moderate match

~$18–30

03Borouj (Dumont Paris)Perlador

Perlador

by Borouj (Dumont Paris)

Low match

~$45–90

A hard-to-find, high-priced ($300-370) Parfums de Marly fruity-oriental (green apple, nutmeg, rose, tonka, vanilla, patchouli), Carlisle gets far less Reddit-specific chatter than mainstream PdM releases like Layton or Delina — searches of r/fragrance and r/fragranceclones turned up no dedicated Carlisle threads. The real consensus lives on Fragrantica/Basenotes forum threads and a cluster of independent YouTube 'vs Carlisle' comparison videos, plus direct clone-house branding. Dua Fragrances' Cumbria is the most consistently cited and note-accurate match (near-identical listed notes: green apple, nutmeg, tonka, rose, vanilla, patchouli), sold explicitly as a Carlisle dupe. Ard Al Zaafaran's Tafakhar is a frequently-reviewed budget option (6+ independent YouTube comparisons, retailer-labeled 'Inspired By Carlisle') but is described as a looser, more divisive interpretation with an oud/incense twist and a strong, synthetic-leaning opening. Borouj's Perlador is repeatedly mentioned as 'a smell of Carlisle' but by most accounts (including its own reviewers) is only a partial/base-note match — its top and heart notes (sage, basil, incense, leather, oud) diverge significantly and it only converges toward Carlisle's warm vanilla-patchouli character in the dry-down. Several other names surfaced in SEO/AI-generated blog aggregators (Alexandria Fragrances 'Royal Equestrian', Lattafa 'Ameer Al Oudh Intense', 'Fragrance World Carlisle') were checked directly and excluded: Royal Equestrian is verifiably a Layton clone (not Carlisle) per Alexandria's own product page, the Lattafa link could not be substantiated anywhere, and Fragrance World's 'Carlisle' listing has a note profile (sea notes, melon, galbanum, cedar, sandalwood, musk) that doesn't resemble the real Carlisle at all, with only a generic 'spot on dupe' customer blurb as support.