4 clones found

01Alexandria FragrancesPlum Lucky

Plum Lucky

by Alexandria Fragrances

● Top pickHigh match

~$30–40

02LattafaIshq Al Shuyukh Silver

Ishq Al Shuyukh Silver

by Lattafa

Moderate match

~$20–30

03Fragrance WorldHayaati Royale

Hayaati Royale

by Fragrance World

Moderate match

~$20–30

04NikeUltra Green Man

Ultra Green Man

by Nike

Low match

~$10–15

Rabanne (formerly Paco Rabanne) 1 Million Lucky (2018) is a sweet, fruity-gourmand men's fragrance built on green apple/plum and grapefruit up top, a signature creamy hazelnut and honey heart, and a woody amber/cedar base. The community consensus is that Lucky is notoriously hard to clone well because that hazelnut-plum creaminess is its defining, hard-to-replicate signature; most alternatives nail the sweet fruity-woody drydown but come up short in the opening. The clearest dedicated clone is Alexandria Fragrances 'Plum Lucky,' repeatedly cited as the closest one-to-one match. Lattafa's Ishq Al Shuyukh Silver is the most popular budget alternative and is widely described as roughly 90% there, though fresher and more ambery and missing the hazelnut/plum. Nike Ultra Green Man is an ultra-cheap option that captures the fruity-honey vibe but reads noticeably different and performs weakly. Fragrance World's Hayaati Royale is a newer, toffee-apple-forward marketed clone with lighter corroboration. Honest caveats: none fully reproduce the hazelnut signature; performance on the budget options (especially Nike) is weak; and shoppers must be careful with the '1 Million' family, since many products (e.g., Armaf Tag Him Prestige) clone the original 1 Million rather than Lucky. Joop! Homme EDP is often name-dropped as a similar-vibe designer alternative but is not a dedicated clone.